Sabrina Carpenter Sparks Debate Over Aritzia Coat Tag in NYC

Pop star Sabrina Carpenter has ignited a lively discussion regarding fashion norms after she was spotted in New York City wearing the popular $300 Slouch Babaton coat from Aritzia. During a recent lunch outing, Carpenter retained the large rectangular fabric tag sewn onto the sleeve, a detail that has drawn mixed reactions from fans and fashion commentators alike.

The incident occurred in October 2023, as the city transitioned into its annual “giant, cozy coat season.” Many observers were quick to comment on the tag’s presence, which is often removed by buyers. Carpenter’s choice to leave it attached has led some to question whether this makes her one of the most relatable off-duty dressers in the public eye, especially as comparisons are drawn to Taylor Swift, who has shifted from sustainable brands to luxury labels.

Opinions on the tag’s aesthetic value vary greatly. Some fashion enthusiasts advocate for its immediate removal, likening it to cutting a coat vent stitch. Others, however, express hesitation at the risk of damaging their garments or simply prefer the decorative element. “It looks tacky not to take the tag off,” says Brooke LaMantia, an editorial assistant at The Cut, who owns the same coat. LaMantia noted that when she tried on the coat, she found it to be both warm and stylish, especially when buttoned up for windy days.

The Slouch Babaton coat has received praise for its versatility. Catherine Thompson, a features editor at The Cut, highlighted its roomy shoulders, which comfortably accommodate chunky sweaters underneath. She emphasized its chic appearance, stating, “It also just looks very expensive — as long as you cut the damn sleeve tag!”

As the debate continues, many fans are sharing their thoughts on social media, with a significant number urging fellow shoppers to remove the tags. This discussion reflects broader trends in fashion, where consumers are increasingly mindful of brand representation and personal style choices. In a culture where authenticity is valued, Carpenter’s decision to keep the tag could be interpreted as a statement on individuality and comfort.

In a world where celebrity fashion often sets trends, Carpenter’s outing has made waves beyond mere style. It has prompted conversations about the intersection of fashion, branding, and personal expression. Whether she becomes a symbol of relatable fashion or a cautionary tale remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the Slouch coat has sparked a dialogue that resonates with many.