Discover 8 Must-Play Mystery Games for Halloween 2025 NOW

UPDATE: With Halloween just around the corner, gamers are buzzing about the top mystery games to play this spooky season. For those who prefer intrigue over jump scares, a selection of eight captivating titles has surfaced, promising haunting atmospheres and gripping narratives that keep players engaged without overwhelming them with horror.

As of October 2025, these mystery games are trending among players looking for a different kind of thrill. Here’s a look at the must-plays that are redefining Halloween entertainment, making them perfect for the curious at heart.

1. The Wolf Among Us (2013)
This episodic gem from Telltale Games immerses you in the gritty world of Fabletown, where fairy tale characters live in a dark, noir setting. Players step into the shoes of Bigby Wolf, navigating moral dilemmas and uncovering hidden secrets that reveal the dark side of fairy tales. Its atmospheric storytelling makes it a unique addition to your Halloween gaming lineup.

2. What Remains of Edith Finch (2017)
Celebrated for its poignant exploration of death and family, this game invites players to unravel the tragic stories of the Finch family. As you explore their home, the haunting beauty of each narrative intertwines with the unsettling presence of the past, making it a deeply emotional experience that resonates long after the game ends.

3. Dredge (2023)
Labelled as ‘cozy horror’, Dredge combines fishing mechanics with Lovecraftian elements that creep up on players. Gamers navigate serene waters, only to uncover unsettling relics and mysteries lurking beneath the surface. The calm fishing expeditions turn tense, proving that not all horrors are loud; some hide in shadows.

4. Gone Home (2013)
Set in a thunderstorm-lashed manor, this mystery game challenges players to uncover the fate of a missing family. With a runtime of approximately two hours, it delivers a powerful narrative that explores personal connections and revelations, proving that true horror often lies in the familiar.

5. The Sinking City Remastered (2025)
Set against a backdrop of Lovecraftian lore, players explore the decaying city of Oakmont, shrouded in mystery and conspiracy. This open-world detective game demands players solve intertwined crimes while grappling with the eerie atmosphere, making it a compelling choice for mystery enthusiasts this Halloween.

6. House of Ashes (2021)
Part of Supermassive Games’ Dark Pictures Anthology, this title follows soldiers during the Iraq War who discover an ancient temple filled with secrets. The game’s moral dilemmas and mythological themes keep players on edge without crossing into outright horror, delivering a suspenseful experience.

7. Return of the Obra Dinn (2018)
This unique title places players on a ghostly ship, piecing together the fates of its crew using a magical pocket watch. Its distinctive art style and deep investigative gameplay create an unsettling atmosphere that captivates players, proving that the absence of jump scares doesn’t diminish the suspense.

8. Hell is Us (2025)
This newly released game thrusts players into a war-torn world, blending personal and external conflicts. As players navigate the complexities of Hadea, they confront their inner demons alongside physical threats, making it a profound experience that challenges perceptions of horror.

These eight titles offer an alternative to traditional horror games this Halloween, appealing to those who crave narrative depth and atmospheric tension. As gaming evolves, these mystery games are set to become staples for players looking to engage in a different kind of spooky season fun.

Whether you prefer exploring emotional tales or unraveling complex mysteries, each game provides an engaging experience that keeps the spirit of Spooktober alive. Don’t miss out—dive into these captivating worlds and share your experiences with fellow gamers. The countdown to Halloween is on, and these games are sure to pull you in!