Duxbury Mother Seeks Trial Move Amid Controversial Case

UPDATE: Lindsay Clancy, the Duxbury mother charged with the tragic murders of her three children, is seeking to move her trial out of Plymouth County, citing concerns over media exposure. Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, argues that an impartial jury cannot be formed due to “exploitive prejudicial publicity” surrounding the case.

The prosecution, however, is pushing back. Plymouth Second Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague contends that Reddington’s claims are unfounded, stating that a “deliberate and thoughtful individual voir dire process” will ensure a fair jury selection. The trial is currently set to begin on February 9, 2024, but Reddington is also requesting a delay, suggesting it be postponed until next spring.

Lindsay Clancy, aged 35, faces charges for allegedly strangling her children—Cora, aged 5; Dawson, aged 3; and Callan, just 8 months old. The prosecution asserts that Clancy used ligature strangulation, requiring her to maintain pressure for up to five minutes on each child to cause death. Following the incident on January 24, 2023, authorities claim Clancy attempted suicide, resulting in a fall that has left her paralyzed and confined to a wheelchair.

In his motion for a venue change, Reddington highlighted the extensive media coverage and its potential impact on the trial’s fairness. He stated, “the unavoidable conclusion is that Lindsay Clancy cannot be given a fair trial in Plymouth County.” However, Sprague counters that Reddington himself contributed to the media frenzy by discussing the case with reporters, which undermines his argument.

“Defense counsel’s bid for a new venue seems disingenuous after he courted the media at the inception of the case,” Sprague wrote, emphasizing the need for transparency in the judicial process.

Reddington is pursuing an insanity defense, claiming Clancy was emotionally unstable during the tragic events. He has pointed to her struggles with postpartum depression as a significant factor in her mental state that night.

The next hearing in this high-profile case is scheduled for Tuesday morning at Plymouth Superior Court, where further developments are anticipated. With public interest and emotional weight surrounding this case, all eyes will be on how the court navigates the complexities of justice and media influence.