MLB Predictions Graded: A’s Fail, Pirates Shine in 2025 Season

UPDATE: The MLB predictions for the 2025 season have been graded, revealing stunning successes and major disappointments across all 30 teams. As fans review the season’s outcomes, some teams soared while others fell flat, highlighting the unpredictable nature of baseball.

The Pittsburgh Pirates dominated expectations as Paul Skenes not only clinched the Cy Young Award but also delivered one of the best seasons for any Pirates starter since 1920. His remarkable stats include a 7.7 WAR and a 1.97 ERA. Analysts are already speculating about Skenes’ potential to achieve a 9- or 10-WAR season in 2026.

In the Seattle Mariners camp, Bryan Woo proved to be the team’s ace, finishing with a 15-7 record and a 2.94 ERA. His performance, which included a historic 25 consecutive starts of six innings or more, earned him a place among the top Cy Young contenders. Woo’s health will be critical as the Mariners eye a World Series run next year.

Meanwhile, the Cleveland Guardians saw Gavin Williams shine in the rotation, leading in both ERA and WAR with a 3.06 ERA and 3.8 WAR. His performance has set high expectations for 2026, especially if he can reduce his walk rate.

On the flip side, the Los Angeles Angels faced challenges despite hitting a lot of home runs. They ended the season with 90 losses and a team batting average of just .225, highlighting a need for offensive balance going into next season. The Angels also led the league in strikeouts, raising questions about their hitting strategy.

The New York Yankees shocked many by finishing with a 94-68 record, defying predictions of a losing season. The team’s strong performance was bolstered by key players like Aaron Judge, who had another stellar year.

In an unexpected turn, the Toronto Blue Jays decided to extend Vladimir Guerrero Jr. with a staggering $500 million contract, a move that contradicted earlier trade predictions. Guerrero’s postseason heroics, including a .397 batting average in the playoffs, have solidified his status as a franchise cornerstone.

As teams begin planning for 2026, fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see how these predictions and performances influence offseason strategies. With free agency looming and teams evaluating their rosters, the upcoming months will be critical for shaping the future of MLB.

Stay tuned for more updates as the offseason unfolds!